19 March 2002

I’ve been reading a bit about advertising today, and was struck by an interesting contrast in these letters to Advertising Age. Near the top (letter dates 13 March 2002) is a reprint of Leo Burnett’s marvelous farewell speech to his company in 1967 — honorable, wise, and really a testament to what is good in that strange industry. Scroll a little further down, though, and you find (on 20 February 2002) something from yet another ad schmucky with the jones to Brand America.” What Leo could tell Schmucky is that America is already branded, and by the kind of horrible “advertising” that made Leo B. threaten to come back from the dead to take his name off the company door if need be. The connection may not be immediately clear, but it’s worth your meditating on for a minute.

19 March 2002

17 March 2002

Kevin Kelly’s got an interesting piece on technology and music in today’s NY Times Magazine. The best part is the historical analysis, which is really quite good. The forward-looking stuff isn’t all it could be; he lists a number of factors that’ll change what we expect from music in the future, but I think he’s missed the convenience angle entirely — it is, after all, easier to immediately search out and download a song one hears and likes than to jot down the title and artist and remember to look for the CD next time you’re in a record store, assuming of course that your tastes aren’t too esoteric to be served by such stores. And he is still Kevin Kelly, which means he’s entirely ignoring the darker forces in the market (particularly pay-per-play, in which you have to re-purchase your favorite song Every Time You Play It). Worth your time, but don’t believe the hype.

17 March 2002